Behind the Scenes OSI

Satellite companies restrict journalists’ access to images from the Iran War

In the days after a missile slammed into a girls elementary school in Minab, Iran on Feb. 28 killing about 175 people, most of them children, open source investigation teams at news organizations used satellite images and videos to probe the source of the attack. Now, two of the largest providers of satellite imagery, Planet Labs and Vantor, are limiting access to images from across the Middle East. Going forward, the companies will apply a two-week hold on all images in the companies’ image archives — exactly the kind of images that journalists used to conclude that a Tomahawk missile fired by the U.S. was probably responsible for the deadly attack on the school.

President Trump has denied U.S. involvement in the missile attack, while Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth said it is still under investigation, adding “open source is not the place to determine what did or did not happen.”

Both Planet Labs and Vantor have extensive contracts with the federal government, including the military and intelligence agencies. In a statement, Planet said the move was taken “after consulting with experts inside and outside of government… in an effort to limit any uncontrolled distribution ​of the images that might result in their unintentional access and use as tactical leverage by adversarial ​actors.”

Vantor denied that the restrictions were made at the request of the government, adding in a statement that “during times of geopolitical conflict, Vantor may implement enhanced access controls to prevent the misuse of sensitive geospatial intelligence.”

Image shows satellite photo of area surrounding school with the adjacent military compound and walls highlighted.
A graphic from The Washington Post’s Visual Forensics team of the missile attack on the elementary school in southern Iran used satellite imagery from Vantor.

High stakes for investigative journalism

Investigative teams using open-source methods at The New York Times, Bellingcat, The Washington Post, the BBC and other news organizations used satellite images to show that a precision weapon had hit the school in Minab and videos to identify the type of missile. It’s just the most recent example of how analyzing satellite images and videos has revolutionized investigative journalism, from documenting war crimes in Ukraine to contradicting the official story of the shooting by federal agents of Alex Pretti in Minneapolis.

DON’T MISS  Alvin Chang shows how to visualize Sci-Fi’s Growing Pessimism

The quality of Planet’s images are particularly useful in investigations like the missile strike. “Planet’s high res imagery allowed us to analyze multiple strikes on the [adjacent] military base and the primary school,” explained Merlyn Thomas of the BBC’s Verify investigative team in a post on Instagram.

Side-by-side photos of missiles that appear to be of identical types.
In order to confirm the type of missile that hit near the school, Bellingcat compared a video from the airstrike in Minab (left) to a Tomahawk missile flying over Tehran earlier in the conflict.

“In cases like the Minab missile attack, timely satellite imagery is essential for verifying damage, locating impacts, and cross-checking eyewitness content and other open-source evidence,” said Carlos Gonzalez, head of research for Bellingcat. “A two-week delay slows the verification process and makes it more difficult to establish facts while events are still developing.”

“The main effect of the delay is on the level of certainty we can achieve quickly,” he continued. “Without near-real-time images, our findings require more careful qualification until visual confirmation becomes possible.”

Gonzalez says Bellingcat will continue to innovate around obstacles. “Even when the most recent imagery is unavailable, older satellite data can still support geolocation, terrain mapping, infrastructure analysis, and contextualization of ground-level videos or photos…. When access to one source is limited, we adapt by combining alternative sources to corroborate events and strengthen the evidentiary record.”

Dan Zedek
Latest posts by Dan Zedek (see all)
DON’T MISS  WNYC analyzes traffic tickets to find speed cameras